EU hydrogen targets are ‘impossible’ as green H2 costs eight times as much as grey H2 today: Total CEO
EU hydrogen targets are ‘impossible’ as green H2 costs eight times as much as grey H2 today: Total CEO
May 4, 2024
TotalEnergies CEO Patrick Pouyanné has lambasted the EU’s target to use 20 million tonnes of green hydrogen by 2030 as “impossible” based on current costs and the relative infancy of electrolyser technology.“For hydrogen, [the cost of] grey hydrogen to blue hydrogen is 1:2, to green hydrogen it’s supposed to be 1:3,” he said at a recent special meeting of World Economic Forum.However, TotalEnergies is currently running a tender for 500,000 tonnes of renewable H2 for use in its refineries, and the prices that have emerged are much, much higher.“If we get the 500,000 tonnes on an average of €8 [$8.57] per kilogram — this is more or less the average of the offers, so it’s not €3 or €5. Don’t dream: today it’s €8, and €8 for the best,” he said.“If I’m paying €8 per kilogram, compared to €1 [for grey hydrogen], you know there is something to be absorbed,” he added.However, Pouyanné noted that the tender is viable due to Europe’s Emissions Trading System, which not only charges industrial emitters per tonne of CO2, but also awards free allowances for green hydrogen producers.“If a refinery is using green hydrogen and replacing this grey hydrogen, not only I will avoid…
Read more
Plug Power signs preliminary deal to supply 3GW of electrolysers to Australian green hydrogen and ammonia project
Plug Power signs preliminary deal to supply 3GW of electrolysers to Australian green hydrogen and ammonia project
May 4, 2024
US manufacturer Plug Power has signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Australian developer Allied Green Ammonia (AGA) to supply 3GW of PEM electrolysers from 2027 for a planned project in Australia’s Northern Territory.AGA plans to take a final investment decision next year on its Green Ammonia Production Facility, which it plans to build on the Gove Peninsula in the far northeast of the territory from 2027.According to AGA, the project — which will produce 2,500 tonnes of green ammonia a day, or more than 900,000 tonnes annually — “will be one of the most energy efficient green hydrogen and green ammonia projects globally”.The partners plan to agree on a deal for Plug to provide a Basic Engineering and Design Package (also known as a front-end engineering design, or FEED) for the 3GW project.“Our MOU with Plug builds on a long list of leading global firms who are joining us on our journey to build one of the largest green ammonia production facilities in the world, in a strategically located part of Australia given its proximity to Asia,” said AGA managing director Alfred Benedict.(Copyright)
Read more
‘We won’t sign clean hydrogen offtake deals until we get the right price — despite investor pressure’: Air Products CEO
‘We won’t sign clean hydrogen offtake deals until we get the right price — despite investor pressure’: Air Products CEO
May 4, 2024
Air Products’ CEO Seifi Ghasemi has pushed back on analyst concerns that there will not be sufficient demand for blue and green hydrogen by 2030 to justify the industrial gases firm’s early investments into major projects.“The part that I can confidently tell the investors, believe me, there is demand,” he said during the company’s second quarter earning call. “Do not buy into this business that there is no demand. There is demand.”Air Products has agreed to offtake all the green ammonia being produced at the 2.2GW Neom complex currently under construction in Saudi Arabia for a 30-year period. The firm is also a shareholder on the project, which reached a $8.4bn financial close last year.However, the offtake deal is a huge bet that whatever price the industrial gases firm has agreed to buy at, there will be third-party buyers willing to pay more, once the project comes on line at the end of 2026 or beginning of 2027.Similarly, the company is developing a $4.5bn blue hydrogen and ammonia project in Louisiana, set to be fully commissioned in 2028, which would produce more than 1,770 tonnes of H2 per day.However, Air Products has not signed third-party offtake agreements for either megaproject,…
Read more
Green iron from waste products | Final permits secured for full-scale green-hydrogen DRI plant in Sweden
Green iron from waste products | Final permits secured for full-scale green-hydrogen DRI plant in Sweden
April 30, 2024
A Swedish company building a pioneering green iron project that will use hydrogen to make tens of thousands of tonnes of direct-reduced iron (DRI, also known as sponge iron) has received the final permits it needs to build and operate its plant.GreenIron has been granted permission by the Land and Environment Court in Östersund to process up to 30,000 tonnes per year of waste material to make up to 21,000 tonnes of DRI per year at its full-scale plant currently under construction in Sandviken,120km north of Stockholm.The project — which is scheduled to come on line this year —will use 1,000 tonnes of green hydrogen per year, supplied by industrial gases firm Linde under a firm binding contract that has already been agreed, GreenIron told Hydrogen Insight.Green hydrogen-based DRI (together with electric arc furnace smelting) has been touted as the most promising pathway to decarbonise steel production, which accounts for 7-8% of all global emissions, predominantly on account of the use of coking coal as a reduction agent to make pure iron suitable for steelmaking (see panel below).But unlike most commercial-scale DRI plants typically operated by steel manufacturers, which usually process iron ore that has been mined, into sponge iron,…
Read more
Older News
German gas distributor says network is ready for 30% hydrogen blend following successful pilot scheme
April 30, 2024
A gas distributor in Germany says its network is ready for hydrogen blends of up to 30%, following a successful pilot project in its home state of Baden-Württemberg.Stuttgart-based Netze BW — the largest electricity, gas and water network operator in the state — said that its gas distribution network is “fundamentally capable of transporting climate-friendly hydrogen” after completing its Hydrogen Island Öhringen scheme.The project involved a Netze BW property and 26 adjacent households in which the amount of hydrogen in an islanded gas grid was gradually increased until it hit a blend of 30% H2 (and 70% natural gas).“The 30% hydrogen addition worked without any problems,” said Martin Konermann, Netze BW’s managing director for technology. “No complex adjustments to the existing infrastructure were necessary — neither for Netze BW with regard to the gas network, not for end consumers with regard to their gas boilers and stoves.”Last week, Brussels-based non-profit organisation Environmental Coalition on Standards released a report saying that it found that a 20% hydrogen blend more than doubled leaks from existing domestic gas cookers compared to using fossil gas, when used under normal household conditions. And it added that existing gas boilers saw an emissions increase of 44%…
Read more
US finalises new rules that will allow clean hydrogen producers to sell tax credits
April 30, 2024
The US government has today (Friday) finalised a rule that will allow producers of clean hydrogen to sell tax credit subsidies to other taxpayers in exchange for cash, which officials say will help developers secure financial backers and speed up the pace of development.The new transferability rule — one of two options now available for monetising tax credits — drawn up by the Department of the Treasury and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS, the federal tax authorities), will apply to producers eligible for 11 different tax credit subsidies across the Inflation Reduction Act, including the 45V production tax credit for clean hydrogen.Developers utilising the 45Q tax credit for carbon capture and storage — which includes some blue hydrogen producers — will also be eligible for the programme, as will those using the 48C credit for “advanced energy projects” such as electrolyser factories.When fully finalised by regulators, the 45V credit will allow eligible producers of clean hydrogen to claim a maximum of $3 back in tax credits on each kg of H2 they produce.However, some developers will take some time to be profitable, meaning that they may not have a high enough tax bill to offset against the value of the…
Read more
Recent headwinds on green hydrogen roll-out are ‘constructive’, not a sign of looming failure: RMI
April 19, 2024
The Rocky Mountain Institute (RMI), a US non-profit organisation, expects 2024 will be a year of “significant progress” for green hydrogen despite major headwinds. A growing number of green hydrogen projects have been shelved or scrapped this year amid rising costs, while delays to the roll-out of production tax credits in the US and H2 subsidies in the EU have resulted in slower-than-expected progress in the industry. EXCLUSIVE | This Shell-backed project to ship vast volumes of liquid green hydrogen from Portugal to the Netherlands has been scrapped Read more RMI also notes that the International Energy Agency has revised down its figures for how much hydrogen will be needed to meet net zero by 2050, in part due to the expectation that more sectors will be directly electrified rather than depending on H2. However, the sustainability-focused research institute remains positive about the sector's progress. “We believe these are signs of constructive iteration in the market, not of looming failure,” it wrote in a blogpost entitled: “Hydrogen State of the Union”. RMI expects that 2024 will be a take-off year for green hydrogen as a sector for a number of reasons.Article continues below the advert Firstly, supportive policy either directly…
Read more
Sunfire begins design work for one of Europe’s largest green hydrogen projects
April 18, 2024
German electrolyser manufacturer Sunfire has begun designing the set-up for a massive 500MW green hydrogen project in Europe, which would be one of the continent’s largest if it comes on line as scheduled in 2028. The mystery project — which has not yet reached final investment decision (FID) and has not been identified by Sunfire — would produce green hydrogen from wind and solar power for use in various applications, including refinery operations and ammonia production. Sunfire’s participation in the on-going front-end engineering and design (FEED) study for the project envisages the company defining the operational parameters, site requirements and execution guidelines for the installation and operation of 500MW of its pressurised alkaline electrolysers. “Europe is at the forefront of adopting green hydrogen solutions,” said Nils Aldag, Sunfire’s chief executive. “We are seeing the first 100MW projects reaching their FIDs. As larger-scale projects like the 500MW initiative emerge, Sunfire reaffirms its commitment to providing reliable industrial electrolyser technology, capable of facilitating transformative projects.” There are few green hydrogen projects of this scale at advanced stages of development, but there are several that are still in the preliminary stage. For example, Tree Energy Solutions and EWE’s 500MW green gas and green…
Read more
Nel’s quick cash from Nikola renegotiation buoys slow quarter for hydrogen electrolyser orders
April 17, 2024
Norwegian electrolyser maker Nel saw its losses shrink in the first quarter of 2024 — mainly buoyed by NKr96m ($8m) of extra revenue from a renegotiated deal with truck manufacturer Nikola. Nel had originally signed a supply agreement with Nikola in 2018, which included a firm purchase order of 85MW of electrolysers and refuelling equipment for the latter’s Phoenix Hydrogen Hub in Arizona. However, in the following years, Nikola sold the Phoenix Hydrogen Hub to Australia’s Fortescue, which reduced the scope to 80MW although the original capacity had already been delivered. In February, Nel and Nikola cancelled their old supply agreement and agreed to a new deal for 110 stacks and balance-of-stack equipment — which corresponds to 275MW of capacity, although this is not a firm order and therefore not recognised in the order backlog. However, since the old deal also included refuelling equipment, Nel was compensated with $9m in total from Nikola, although only $8m was recognised this quarter. Our customers are waiting for that [subsidy] cash, and until they have that cash, they’re not willing to go ahead and place a firm purchase order with Nel or any other [manufacturer] This extra, cost-free cash meant that the Norwegian…
Read more
‘EU steel industry will need more subsidised green H2 than European Hydrogen Bank can provide’: trade body
April 17, 2024
The European steel industry needs five million tonnes of green hydrogen a year to fully decarbonise and the European Hydrogen Bank (EHB) funding mechanism is not furnished with enough cash to achieve this, Europe’s steel production trade association has told Hydrogen Insight. Steel producers need green hydrogen to cleanly extract iron from ore through the direct-iron reduction (DRI) process, in place of coke-fired blast furnaces, so as to minimise their 7-8% contribution to all global carbon emissions. It will need to cost no more than €2-3/kg ($2.13-3.19/kg), a spokesperson for industry association Eurofer said, which implies the need for significant subsidies. The cost of green hydrogen in Europe is expected to be in the region of €4.50-6/kg, according to analyst S&P Global Platts. “[But] the European Hydrogen Bank has not enough firepower for the huge task it has been set,” the spokesperson explained, referring to the EHB’s €800m pilot auction, launched in November with the aim of bridging the gap between grey hydrogen made with fossil gas and renewable H2. Europe’s first DRI plants are due to come on line in 2025-27, with at least two incumbent German developers putting out tenders for thousands of tonnes of green hydrogen by…
Read more
‘No place in our homes’ | Hydrogen blends leak twice as much in household cookers compared to gas: report
April 17, 2024
Blending up to 20% hydrogen into fossil gas networks — as many operators hope to do — could massively increase leaks from normal household appliances such as cookers and boilers, and wipe out any climate benefit of using expensive H2 in the first place, lab tests have revealed. Tests carried out in a UK certified lab (but not peer-reviewed) on behalf of environmental non-profit the Environmental Coalition on Standards (Ecos) found that using a 20% hydrogen blend in methane more than doubled leaks from domestic gas cookers compared to using fossil gas alone, when used under normal household conditions. Boilers tested by UK scientists at Enertek International saw emissions increase by 44% on average. Leakages of just 0.7% — likely in most homes on most days, the test shows —would cause additional annual greenhouse-gas emissions equivalent to 574,538 tonnes of carbon dioxide if applied to all households in the EU, and 155,755 tonnes in the UK, equivalent to the emissions from 300,000 and 84,000 fossil fuel-powered cars, respectively. Crucially, this would mean that the climate benefit of blending 20% hydrogen into the gas — estimated at a 7% reduction in emissions due to the lower volumetric energy density of H2…
Read more